MOSTLY FALSE: „20% of the companies covered by the CBAM are responsible for 97% of the emissions”

During a public hearing at the European Parliament’s Subcommittee on Tax Matters (FISC) on 6 February 2025, Dutch Commissioner for Climate Action Wopke Hoekstra claimed that only 20% of companies are responsible for around 97% of the emissions. His claim turns out to be mostly false. Public hearing at the Committee on Tax Matters (FISC)…

mostly false

Mostly False: “Dual citizenship will become the rule in our citizenship law”

On January 8, 2025, Friedrich Merz, the Federal Chancellor of Germany, stated in an interview with the newspaper Welt that “Dual citizenship will thus become the rule in our citizenship law” and that “it will bring additional problems into the country.” To assess this statement, we first examine whether dual citizenship has indeed become the…

mostly false

Mostly false: “Immigration costs Germany €6 trillion”

On January 11, 2024, the German extreme-right party „Alternative for Germany“ published an article in its digital member magazine afdkompakt.de claiming that immigration costs Germany €6 trillion, which is seen as evidence for the need of remigration. The source for this statement is a study published in January by economist Bernd Raffelhüschen. The AfD’s interpretation…

mostly false

Mostly false: “Nuclear energy is CO₂-neutral”

During an appearance on the German political talkshow „Farbe bekennen“, AfD-chairwoman Alice Weidel states that nuclear energy is CO₂-neutral (08:33). This claim relies on the fact that the actual process of nuclear energy production does not cause any carbon emissions. However, regarding the entire lifespan of a nuclear energy plant and the carbon emissions that are…

Mostly false: “Only around 3% of all CO₂ emissions are man-made”

“Only around 3% of all CO₂ emissions are man-made, i.e. they come from the economy, heating and transportation. Around 97% of CO₂ emissions are of natural origin.” This is a claim made by Karsten Hilse, a climate spokesperson for Germany’s far-right party AfD, on his website. It’s a claim regularly used to downplay human responsibility…